Actress Reina Hardesty Talks Starring in Netflix’s It’s What’s Inside

Reina Hardesty’s star is on the rise.

Known for her previous roles in Brockmire, StartUp and the Arrowverse as Weather Witch, the 28-year-old actress plays eccentric party girl Brooke in Netflix’s latest film It’s What’s Inside — the body-swapping dark comedy where she gets to show off her acting chops as not one, not two, but three different characters.

Us Weekly chatted with the Hollywood up-and-comer about the movie’s surprising twists and turns, its message in a social media world, and why you may not want to watch it alone. Her advice — don’t blink because you might miss something.

You recently went to the premiere of It’s What’s Inside. How many times have you seen the film?

This was my third time seeing it. It’s been a while, I guess almost 10 months, since I’ve seen it last.

I don’t want to give it away, but the actors play so many different characters. So every time you’ve see it, do you see something new or take away something totally different?

I think as an actor, the first time you watch it, as much as you would like to try to view it objectively, it’s, it’s kind of impossible. Because we know what it was like every day. We know what the script was like originally and if there were any changes — and we’re watching to see like, am I happy with how it went?

The first time watching it, it definitely felt more like that the second time. Seeing it, especially with the crowd at Sundance, was really exciting this time. I was able to really lean into appreciating everybody’s performances with their nuances that they were leaning into. There was a scene that really broke my heart in a way that hadn’t before. [It is] the scene where, when Shelby (played by Brittany O’Grady) is in Nikki’s body (played by Alycia Debnam-Carey) asking Cyrus (played by James Morosini) in Forbes’s body (played by David W. Thompson), ‘Do you not find me attractive?’ It really broke my heart and amazed me. I felt a lot more emotionally affected by it this time around.

How would you describe this movie?

It’s a movie about identity and whether or not you can trust the people around you. I would say it’s important to go into it not knowing too much. I really think that people need to watch it with a group of friends because I think people can see themselves in the characters and it’s just more fun that way to react to all the crazy twists and turns and the pacing. It’s so fast-paced. I also would recommend to not go on your phone at any point, because if you miss a second, you might miss a lot. Don’t mindlessly open Instagram, but I don’t think people will because it’s so engaging. It’s a fun movie. Just enjoy yourself [and] lean into the craziness of it.

I wasn’t expecting the twists and turns which made it so entertaining to watch. Everybody is sort of thrown into this situation playing all of these different characters. Was that a huge draw for you as an actress?

It’s any actor’s dream to have the possibility to play multiple characters in one film. And, you know, it’s a challenge and it’s scary, but I felt like reading the script, it was so clear that [writer-director] Greg [Jardin] knew what he wanted to do. there was such style and almost like a sense of humor and a buoyancy in the way that he wrote and presented everything where it was like, oh, this is gonna be really fun. And he has great ideas with the RGB filters and the Polaroids as to how to keep everybody straight on who’s in whose body. His specificity made me feel like even if I felt scared sometimes that I could really trust him and the people around me to get it right.

It’s described as a sci-fi horror. Are you a fan of the genre?

I always find it hard to describe this movie as even a horror because it’s not necessarily terrifying, but it is disturbing and psychologically disturbing. I feel like I love horror films. My best friend and I, we watch them together often. Sometimes we’ll do a double feature. Like the other day we watched Texas Chainsaw Massacre and The Hills Have Eyes casually in the middle of the day. We just enjoy the thrill and going through an intense experience like that together, just watching it. But playing [a character] in a horror movie, you know, it’s fun. It’s a lot of fun, but it can get really intense and exhausting.

Is that how you felt on this film?

I felt like it was definitely intense because we shot this in 18 days. You know, with indie filmmaking a lot of the time you don’t have that much time and it was really intense and it was night shoots. But it was mainly just really fun. With the whole cast, I mean, we were so lucky. The entire cast is so wonderful to be around and wonderful to collaborate with, so it really flew by.

In the film, you’re all good friends who meet up for a reunion. Was it instant cast chemistry? Did you grow into a closeknit cast?

We did. We had a week of rehearsals before starting shooting, which is so rare, especially for indie filmmaking. And It was just so clear from the get go that we were all just game to collaborate and not be too precious about, you know, being protective over our own characters because that’s sometimes the case. That wasn’t really an option here, you know, because we really had to help each other and lean on each other in moments where we were like, well, what would your character do in this moment if you were playing someone else’s character. And I think we were just really lucky that everyone is just genuinely a down to earth, kind person. We spent so much time together in this house, and then we all stayed in the same hotel afterwards as well, and we were constantly spending time together.

This movie is about identity and that really resonates, particularly with social media and how we present ourselves to others by what we post and how we can want be other people too by what we see portrayed online. What is your perception of the film’s message?

I think that everyone in this movie is hiding in one way or another. And I think there’s an inherent loneliness in every person in this group in a different way. I’ll speak on [my character] Brooke in particular. Because who I start with initially, you know, she’s wild, she’s loud, she wants to party and have fun. But I really think that deep down it’s a mask and she just wants to be accepted. And I think that’s Shelby, I think that’s Cyrus in a way. Like he’s seeking intimacy in these places like pornography and online that it can’t really give that to you. And I think that that’s unfortunately a reality now where there’s a sense of artificial intimacy because of how much time that is spent online. And you can feel like you know somebody or know what their life is like by looking at their social media, but you really don’t. And I think we’re all kind of lost in the sauce a bit. And I think this is about getting to know yourself and being satisfied with yourself, and also just being honest with the people around you because the people in this movie are not very honest with one another until they’re, you know, pushed to the limit psychologically because of the circumstances. And then they’re kind of like, well, this is how I really feel. And it’s like, well, maybe none of this would’ve happened if you were all honest with each other and yourself in the first place.

Colman Domingo is an executive producer. What was it like having him part of the project?

I did meet him at Sundance and get to spend more time with him. And we really connected. And he has such a big heart and he’s so passionate about art and what he does, and he loves lifting other people up. And I really admire that about him.

You play Brooke. But you also play other characters. I won’t give too much away, but which ones were your favorites?

I really did love playing all three of the characters. I will say I wish I had some more time with Shelby in my body. It would’ve been more fun to really lean into that because it was the first body swap and it was Shelby’s first time really leaning into it being like, okay, this is fun, and I’m gonna let loose and kind of let go of this anxious grip that she has on control. I would’ve loved to explore that more.

What really scares you in real life?

The first thing that comes to mind is heights. I recently went to Paris for the first time, and I went up the Eiffel Tower, and that was really difficult. And also I’m afraid of the dark, honestly.

You’re also starring opposite Daniel Dae Kim in the upcoming Amazon Prime series Butterfly. What was it like playing an assassin?

It was such a different experience, I’d say for so many reasons. We shot this in South Korea and you know, we were out there for almost six months. And even just being in a different country where you don’t know the language and the crew are all Korean. That just makes it so much harder from the get-go because it’s like, okay, I’m really like a fish out of water. But that really lent itself to the character. She’s an assassin, but she’s struggling to find her identity in the world. And I’m so excited for that one to come out because we worked really, really hard and working with Daniel Dae Kim is a dream. He’s just a wonderful person and a wonderful artist to bounce ideas off of. And he’s such a good leader.

Was there a lot of training involved?

There was [a lot]. I went out there about a month ahead of time to do stunt training. Lots of stunt training because it’s an action espionage. I’m really proud of it.

It’s What’s Inside is now streaming on Netflix.